The Power of Practice

It was Malcolm Gladwell in Outliers, as far as I can tell, who first came up with the notion of the ‘10,000-hour rule’, the one which suggests that success in any sphere of life is almost entirely down to sheer hard work – along, perhaps, with being in the right place at the right time. It’s also an idea which is taken up by Mathew Syad, the three-times Commonwealth table-tennis champion in his best-seller BounceI was particularly struck by his debunking of the myth of the ‘child prodigy’ or the ‘born genius’, which I’m sure most of us have bought into at some stage, it being such a compelling idea (the provocative subtitle of the book is ‘The Myth of Talent and the Power of Practice).

How often do you hear people say that they were always hopeless at spelling or that they couldn’t do maths, the implication being that these ‘talents’ were something you were either born with or not, and they had just happened to be unlucky? For Syad, the idea that the ability to calculate is predetermined at birth is the ultimate expression of the ‘talent’ theory of expertise – we marvel at the feats of those individuals who are able to multiply long strings of digits in a few seconds, as if they are a freak of nature. Yet, according to Syad, there is no magic and no mystery.

“But now consider how much more difficult it is to keep track of a narrative while reading a book. There are tens of thousands of words in the English language, and they are used in new and unforeseen combinations in every sentence of every page. To understand a new sentence, the reader must not only understand its specific meaning, he must also be able to integrate it with all the sentences previously read. He must, for example, remember previously mentioned objects and people in order to resolve references to pronouns.

This is a memory task of almost unimaginable dimensions. And yet most of us are able to get to the last word of the book – comprising hundreds of pages and tens of thousands of words – without once losing the thread of the narrative. The experience we have clocked up as ‘language-users’ enables us to do this in just the same way that the hours clocked up as ‘numbers-users enables mathematicians to get to the end of a multi-digit multiplication by keeping track of the ‘narrative of the calculation.

The difference between calculators and the rest of us, then, is that calculators have spent lives immersed in the vocabulary of numbers, while the rest of us have wimped out by using electronic calculators.”

This is an interesting analogy – and I’m still trying to work out whether it stands up entirely – but it fits quite neatly with my own thinking about the importance of narrative AS learning, as well as its importance IN learning ie that all learning takes place through the creation and sharing of narratives or ‘stories’ (of course we are always sympathetic to theories which chime with our own thinking) . It also makes me wonder whether, when we are quick to criticize those who promise young people that they are capable of becoming anything they choose to be,  instead of dismissing the idea out of hand, perhaps we should simply advise them to ‘remember to tell them about the 10,000 hours!’

About these ads

6 thoughts on “The Power of Practice

  1. Reading this book right now as well, find it very interesting and compelling. I largely agree with what he’s saying, as soon as you start looking behind the “talent” some people allegedly have you almost certainly find a high internal motivation combined with a lot of hard work. Sometimes (in particular in sport) some people have certain genetic advantages (e.g. size, to an extent body shape) which can only partially be compensated by a different style/tactic, so not everyone can do everything, but in general I don’t think he’s too far off.

  2. I also believe that many children are capable of anything given the right encouragement and influence of parents, teachers and sheer hard work. One of my colleagues picked up on an article by Mathew Syad last year and wrote this blog on the same subject.http://wp.me/p1898z-4P . She concentrated on the effects of correctly praising a child to encourage them to reach their full potential. Love reading your blogs!! Margaret Carmichael

    • Thank you Margaret – that’s very kind of you! I will certainly check out your colleague’s blogpost. Don’t know whether you have read Carol Dweck’s ‘Mindset’ but your comment about ‘correctly praising’ is central to her message about developing a growth mindset – with the emphasis on praising the effort rather than the result.

  3. I quite agree with you Armin. Motivation has to be the key. If you transfer the sporting analogies to an educational context, the most significant effect a teacher can have on a young person is to motivate or inspire them to want to be the best. That’s what the best teachers are able to do.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s