Plus Ca Change……….

Compelling evidence has been found to suggest that Curriculum for Excellence is not in fact a vision for education in Scotland in the 21st Century but has been kicking around since the beginning of the 20th! Just look and listen to some of the language in these two texts. The first is from a Headteacher’s retirement speech made in 1904. Amazingly the film clip, from the Scottish Screen Archive of the National Library of Scotland, was recorded in 1938.

George F Duthie, a Victorian Headmaster, retired in 1904. He had been head at Woodside School , Aberdeen , for 50 years. He was also active in the EIS.

The following is from his retirement speech:

 “I taught the children, and they taught me; for I had much to learn of them and from them…The fact of difference of home circumstance – differences of temperament, of degrees of ability, mental and physical, of the power of sympathy and kindly words, became more and more to me elements in the problem of school keeping, and now I’m persuaded that a school curriculum which does not permit of the exercise of all these, carried on in a quiet, deliberate, and I had almost said leisurely way, will fail to develop the kind of men and women we would all like to see taking our places in the world… What we teach is important. How we teach is much more so.”

At the retirement, another teacher said of Mr Duthie that “..he imparted knowledge on true educative lines, sometimes leading in advance, ofttimes accompanying, but never driving, his pupils. He taught them to think for themselves , and he did so with quiet enthusiasm and cheerful kindness. …”



9 thoughts on “Plus Ca Change……….

  1. Loved the the film Bill. I’m going to let a lot of other teachers see this.
    Are you the one with the hammer????


  2. Great clip Bill the PE footage was fantastic to watch. Not much has changed in PE over the past 70 odd years!!! Only joking female PE staff dont wear skirts to teach in these days.

  3. Thanks guys. No, I’m one of the malnourished urchins doing the PE drill in the playground. And our teacher (female) was like an army drill sergeant. The class learning to spell took me right back to my old primary class which had 42 pupils in it.

  4. Is there scope for a wee section on the LTS Online Service – perhaps in the New teachers site – with a few clips on teaching as its been practised/seen at different times and places?
    eg there could be this clip and quote, plus
    perhaps information/links to documentaries (or even dramas) from Britain and abroad eg ‘Etre et Avoir’, which could be used as the basis for discussion/inspiration by trainers and teachers/students.

  5. No problem Louise. Glad you like it. Sorry it’s taken me so long to reply, been out of the country for a couple of weeks.

  6. The photos of your holiday in Turkey are great. Can you put a link with my blog because I want more people to read my blog about Battlefield and also about me.

  7. Glad you like them. I’ll add you to my Blogroll so that people can link to your blog from here. Keep up the good work.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s